Chapter 3 : Muhammad becomes a prophet. | |
Page 33 | Robert heading “ Muhammad becomes a prophet” Robert say Muhammad is prophet |
Page 33, line 1 | Robert again confusion reader Robert use the word before islam Robert one side says Muhammad is the prophet of islam Robert other side syas Islam is new religion |
Chapter-3, page 33, line 2 | Robert again confusing in muslim traditions – “the jews and Christian were expecting a prophet” We ask Robert – Robert – pls check in hindus, jews, Christian tradition that Muhammad is the same prophet which is written in Hindu scripture Jews scripture Christian scripture |
Page 33 Chapter 3, para 1, line 1 | Again Robert making confusion The heading Robert says “ Muhammad becames a prophet “ Then Robert is saying “Muhammad introduced islaam into an Arabian that was a” |
Chatp-3, page 35-para 1, line 1 | Robert don’t believe 1400 years before Muhammad existed, But, Robert believe 1400 years before jewish kingdom existed in same areas, |
Chap-3, Page 35, -para-1, line 7 | Robert believes Christian present at the same time as Muhammad era, Robert believe Christian existed But Robert doubt Muhammad existed |
Chap-3 Page-35, para 3 | Wow Robert doubt existence of Muhammad 1400 years But Robert believe in same time Jewish tribes lives there, Banu Qaynuqa, banu nadir, banu qurayzah, |
Chap-3 Page 35, para-4, line 1,2 | Robert says according to tradition, but Robert forget to say, according to which tradition, Hindus, jews, Christian, zorastarian, |
Chap-3 Page 36, para2, line2 | Robert accept jewish and Christian scripture prophesised his coming |
Chap-3 Page 37, para1, line4-10. | Jews are not crafty enemies, If you see the history many jews have understood prophet Muhammad and became practicing islaam, Robert here want to create a gap between jews and followers of Muhammad Here, Robert using the policies of imperial “ divide and rule” |
Chap-3 Page 37-, para 3, line 5-11. | Robert use a quranic verse to create a gap between jews and hindus But Here Robert forget to mention here quraan says “the jews which donot follow their scripture, The jews who follow jews scripture already understood and became practising Quraan says The pagan( hindus ) who donot follow hindus scripture, hindu follow their own man made religion are enemyk. So Robert, Here you need to understand the essence of word. The people who follow man-made-religion will hate muslims, In muslim community if you see “qaddaffi hate islam, Saleh hate islam Assad hate islam Because they are following man made religion, Quraan says Man made religion follows are enemy of muslim, Where ever they are in jews, chritian, hindus |
Chap-3 Page-37, para 3, line 12 | Robert again you are trying to create hatredness between two community Quraan his not against the Christian, Who follow the teaching of jesus, Quraan his against the christain who follow man-made-teaching Viz. “jesus is not son of god” But few pastor whithout any evidence in injil, they started chaning the religion of jesus, So quraan Is against those who follow the man-made –teaching. Quraan is not against Christian, who follow jesus, |
Chap-3, Page-38, para 1, line 1,2 | Robert again you are confusing ureself If you donot believe in bahira, why you are using bahira story here, |
Chap-3 Page-38, para 2, | Robert, Why you don’t chek the book of Ahmed deedat about chritianity and Muhammad Again you are confusing urself in that period lots of jews and christian start practising islam. Robert as you said, pagan of makka is against muhammad so who accepted Muhammad in starting christian, so Robert be straight you are believing on side jews and Christian expecting Muhammad other side Robert you says jews and Christian is not expecting muahmmad Robert pls be firm on your dialet You are moving like “ round glass without bottom” |
Chap-3 Page-38, para2, line 4 | “ (Muhammad) i have been raised for jihad and i m not raised for tillage “ Prphesis of this words are in veda, jews, scripture, zorastarian scripture, bible scripture is already there This is not new phenomeno, Here Robert What to says that Abraham not fought Moses not fought David not fought Jesus not fought Jeusus is going to fought in last time also... Again here Robert want to make confusion in minds of reader or Robert himself confused. With the theory of ahinsa, In Robert view prophet donot fight “ Robert want to say that prophet do not fight”, So, Abraham, david, Solomon are not prophet, |
Chap-3 Page 38, para 2, line 8,9 | Robert indirectly want to say Robert donot believe Muhammad as a prophet Then I would like to ask him Why Robert choosen a heading with name “Muhammad become a prophet”. Robert confuse himself or trying to confused reader. |
Chap-3 Page-39, para 3, line 2,3,4, | Robert saying according to Islamic tradition, Jewish rabbis, chritian accepted “Muhammad is prophet” If Robert don’t believe Muhammad is as prophet, then why Robert choosen heading as” Muhammad become peophet”. Confusion Robert the name of Robert must change to Robert Spencer to Robert confusion. |
Chap-3 Page -39, para 3, line 9-14 | Robert you hae choosen, correct verse of quraan ( 2:89), Curse of Allaah is on those without faith. Curse of allaah is on those who follow Man-Made-Teaching, |
Chap-3 Page 40, para 3, line 1,2 | Robert Why you are using favourite wife again and again to Aisha, Muhammad love all as equal (all wife) Again Robert Playing a game of divide love and rule Divide love and make division. |
Chap-3 Page-42, para 1, line 1,2,3 | Robert do you know what are writing again you write that followers of Muhammad recited and memorize quraan and collected. |
Page 44, para 2, line 2, 3, 4, | Roberts again you are making unnecessary coments, Women wore hijab because Allaah, Apostle commands, not because of this events, Even followers of jesus wore hijab, Even followers of moses wore hijab, |
Comments